Girlfriends of Christmas Past

Tammin Sursok

Livvy Beal

Brent Bailey

Carter Bolton

Lindsey McKeon

Murphy McCall

Abigail Klein

Zoe Swann

John Brotherton

Anderson Whitmire

Meagan Holder

Megan Walton

Katherine McKalip

Grandma Hattie

Chris Salvatore

Tyler

Bryce Durfee

Beau

Julia Parker

Fran Beal

Jessa Settle

Helena

Matthew P McManus

Bernd

Rebekah Kochan

Biker Mom

Dante Rusciolelli

Biker Dad

Dawn McCoy

Housewife Hostess

Donna Rusch

Lila Croft

Lexi Giovagnoli

Carter's Assistant Carrie

Samuel Engelen

Carter's Nephew Bryce

Hana Engelen

Carter's Niece Bailey

Benjamín T. Díaz

Lila's Son Gregory